If Bergman was an atheist, he bears some resemblance to Friedrich Nietzsche. Although Nietzsche's father was a Lutheran minister, Nietzsche argued that religious ideas disparage man's existence. They suggest that life on Earth is corrupt and evil, and that true value resides in a transcendent beyond where we will become one with God after we die. This view is foolish because, although life on Earth may be full of suffering and violence, it is also full of beauty, and it is only the existence we will know. There is nothing beyond this world.
Bergman seemed to respect Christianity's ability to inspire us to create beauty. He said it was worthwhile to build cathedrals whether or not God existed. The sentiment that religion is false, but uplifting and not altogether bad, is expressed by the priest in the following dialogue from Bergman's 1977 film, The Serpent's Egg:
Manuela: And I try to tell him that we’ll help each other, but that’s only words for him. And everything I say is useless. The only real thing is fear. And I’m sick. I don’t know what’s wrong. Is there any forgiveness?
Priest: Would you like me to pray for you?
Manuela: Do you think that would help?
Priest: I don’t know.
Manuela: Now?
Priest: Yes, now.
Manuela: Is it a special prayer?
Priest: Yes, yes. Let me think.
We ...
We live so far away from God...
...that he probably doesn’t hear us when we pray for help.
So ...
we must help each other, give each other the forgiveness that a remote God denies us.
I...say to you...
...that you are forgiven for your husband’s death. You’re no longer to blame. And I beg your forgiveness...
...for my apathy...
...and my indifference.
Do you forgive me?
Manuela: Yes, I forgive you.
Priest: That’s all we can do. I must hurry. The parish priest becomes annoyed if I’m late.
2 comments:
As a film, The Serpent's Egg fails to achieve what its more distinguished model is mostly famous for: http://bit.ly/alaCl8
You say that Fritz Lang's films simultaneously explored the roots of Nazism in Weimar Germany and told good stories, whereas Serpent's Egg sacrifices the characterization and plot needed for good cinema in order to say something about the roots of Nazism.
I thought Serpent's Egg equated the protagonist, David Carradine's Abel Rosenberg, with Weimar Germany. Both were driven to desperate and self-destructive behavior by poverty. Carradine's rampaging through Berlin in winter was like the Hitler's doomed invasion of the USSR.
Whatever flaws the film has, it is worth watching for Liv Ullman's performance.
Post a Comment